Randolph Scott
Sheriff Mark Rowley
Ann Richards
Henryetta Alcott
George 'Gabby' Hayes
Honest Jim Badger / The Coyote Kid
Ray Collins
Colonel Farewell / Narrator
James Warren
Deputy John Rowley
Morgan Conway
Captain William 'Bill' Hampton
Virginia Sale
Meg
John Halloran
Hank 'Mac' McGee
Andrew Tombes
Doc Quillan
Richard Hale
Ben Wade
Harry Holman
Hodge
Chief Thundercloud
Chief Tahlequah
Lawrence Tierney
Jesse James
Tom Tyler
Frank James
Steve Brodie
Bob Dalton
Nestor Paiva
Sam Bass
Isabel Jewell
Belle Starr
Fred Aldrich
Townsman at Dance (uncredited)
Chet Brandenburg
Townsman (uncredited)
Budd Buster
Doc's Friend (uncredited)
George Chesebro
Johnny (uncredited)
Jack Rube Clifford
Team Owner (uncredited)
Tex Cooper
Tex (uncredited)
John Elliott
Brother Hooker (uncredited)
Herman Hack
Townsman (uncredited)
John Hamilton
Commissioner Taylor (uncredited)
Neal Hart
Townsman (uncredited)
Harry Harvey
Stationmaster (uncredited)
Robert Homans
Judge (uncredited)
Ethan Laidlaw
Lt. Patton (uncredited)
Frank LaRue
Jury Foreman (uncredited)
Elmo Lincoln
Dick Broadwell (uncredited)
Theodore Lorch
Citizen's Committee Member (uncredited)
Wilbur Mack
Cattle Baron (uncredited)
Kermit Maynard
Carson (uncredited)
Robert Milasch
Townsman (uncredited)
Frank Mills
Townsman (uncredited)
Monte Montague
Bartender / Scoreboard-Watcher (uncredited)
Frank O'Connor
Townsman (uncredited)
Artie Ortego
Townsman (uncredited)
Bud Osborne
Dep. Dan Mercer (uncredited)
Emory Parnell
Bitter Creek (uncredited)
Harry 'Snub' Pollard
Town Barber (uncredited)
Bob Reeves
Townsman (uncredited)
Jason Robards Sr.
Alert Coffeyville Citizen (uncredited)
Buddy Roosevelt
Lt. Lake (uncredited)
Harry Semels
Bettor (uncredited)
Boyd Stockman
William McElheney (uncredited)
Bob Walker
Juror (uncredited)
Larry Wheat
Custer (uncredited)
Robert J. Wilke
Deputy Marshal (uncredited)