Johnny Mack Brown
Billy the Kid
Wallace Beery
Pat Garrett
Kay Johnson
Claire
Karl Dane
Swenson
Wyndham Standing
John W. Tunston
Russell Simpson
Angus McSween
Blanche Friderici
Mrs. McSween
Roscoe Ates
Old Stuff
Warner Richmond
Bob Ballinger
James A. Marcus
William P. Donovan
Nelson McDowell
Hatfield
Chris-Pin Martin
Santiago
Marguerita Padula
Nicky Whoosiz
Aggie Herring
Mrs. Hatfield
Hank Bell
Henchman Polka Dot (uncredited)
Frank Ellis
Henchman Joe (uncredited)
Frank Hagney
Bert Grant (uncredited)
Soledad Jiménez
Santiago's Mother (uncredited)
Sarah Padden
Homesteader Mrs. Foster (uncredited)
Frank Reicher
General Lew Wallace (uncredited)
Carl Stockdale
Homesteader Mr. Foster (uncredited)
Blackjack Ward
Outlaw (uncredited)