Laurence Olivier
Priest
Julie Harris
Maria (Priest's Mistress)
George C. Scott
Police Lieutenant
Martin Gabel
Chief of Police
Roddy McDowall
Mestizo
Keenan Wynn
Wine Merchant
Patty Duke
Coral
Lou Antonio
Val Avery
Leonardo Cimino
Frank Conroy
Padre José
Cyril Cusack
Tench
Roger De Koven
Mildred Dunnock
Spinster
Thomas Gomez
Delgado
Rose Gregorio
Mark Lenard
Joanna Merlin
Mildred Natwick
Tim O'Connor
Florence Stanley
Fritz Weaver
James Coco
Soldier (uncredited)