Robert De Niro
Vito Genovese / Frank Costello
Debra Messing
Bobbie Costello
Cosmo Jarvis
Vincent Gigante
Kathrine Narducci
Anna Genovese
Michael Rispoli
Albert Anastasia
Michael Adler
Senator Tobey
Ed Amatrudo
Rudolph Halley
Joe Bacino
Joe Profaci
Anthony J. Gallo
Tommy Lucchese
Wallace Langham
Senator Estes Kefauver
Louis Mustillo
Joe Bonanno
Matt Servitto
George Wolf
Robert Uricola
Tony Bender
Belmont Cameli
Frankie Boy
Carrie Lazar
LT. Trooper
James Ciccone
Carlo Gambino
Bob Glouberman
Victor Riesel
Jeffrey Grover
Judge Liebowitz
Derek Polen
Politician
Abi Van Andel
Judge Peggy Cooper
Zach Meiser
Trooper Vasisko
D.J. Stroud
Push Cart Vendor
Sydney Miles
Young Bobby Costello
Joseph Moreland
Juror
Antonio Cipriano
Young Vito
Brian Scolaro
Paul Castellano
Noah Bain Garret
Abe Telvi
Bryant Carroll
Local Reporter #1 Divorce
Robert Arce
Keith Norval
Luke Stanton Eddy
Young Frank
J. Barrett Cooper
Doctor #2
Wynn Reichert
Doctor #1
Rich Williams
Walter Hawley
Christine McBurney
Trish Hawley
Todd Covert
Edwin Barry - Defense Attorney
Mike Seely
Sheriff Crosswell
Amadeo Fusca
Lucky Luciano
Jennie Malone
Copa Nightclub Patron
Robert DiDonato
Edward Guinan
John Dinello
Joe Barbara
Bret Aaron Knower
Driver
Louie Lawless
Joe the Boss
Mark Tierno
Juror #1
Mark Axelowitz
Asst District Attorney Kamen
Andrew Philpot
Pedestrian
Max Daniels
Anna's Ex Husband (uncredited)
