Carla Gugino
Cathy Rush
Marley Shelton
Sister Sunday
Ellen Burstyn
Mother St. John
David Boreanaz
Ed Rush
Margaret Anne Florence
Rosemary Keenan
Kate Nowlin
Colleen McCann
Malachy McCourt
Monsignor
Phyllis Somerville
Sister Sister
Jodie Lynne McClintock
Sister Thomas
Lauren Bittner
Mary Margaret O'Malley
Lauren Karl
Kelly MacDougal
John Peakes
Harry McHale
Ward Horton
Frankie Sharkey
Brooke Josephson
Mrs. Kincade
Jesse Draper
Mrs. Ballard
Tony Luke Jr.
Salvatore Galentino
Brandon Hannan
Tony Galentino
Christopher Mann
Julius Moore
Josh Green
Cowboy in bar
Pete Postiglione
Security Guard
Michael Smerconish
Reporter #1
Anthony Gargano
Reporter #2
Patrick McDade
Cupcake Buyer
Evan Bochetto
Locker Room Assistant
Gina Allegro
Rosemont Coach (uncredited)
Robert Bizik
Basketball Fan (uncredited)
David E. Brown
Basketball Referee (uncredited)
Rich Bryant
Immaculata Student (uncredited)
Jennifer Butler
Nun (uncredited)
Evangeline
College Student (uncredited)
Basil Kershner
Basketball Fan (uncredited)
Fallon Maressa
Student (uncredited)
Keith Moyer
Biker (uncredited)
Chelsea O'Toole
Nun (uncredited)
Charles Pendelton
Cab Driver / Featured (uncredited)
Vincent Riviezzo
Bank Customer (uncredited)
Mark Schroeder
Scorekeeper #2 (uncredited)
Ryan Tygh
Sporting Goods Stock Boy (uncredited)
Sonny Vellozzi
Scorekeeper (uncredited)
Ryan Windish
Monsignor Assistant (uncredited)
